Site logo
Sticky header logo
Mobile logo
  • Home
  • Unassisted Childbirth
    • What Is UC?
    • Is UC Safe?
    • Why Choose UC?
    • Is UC Legal?
    • An Unassisted Childbirth Advocate Speaks About Midwives
    • How do I get pain relief?
    • Unassisted childbirth in the 1950’s
    • The joys of catching your own baby
    • Unassisted pregnancy: every woman is her own best caregiver
  • Birth Stories
  • Inspiration
    • Inspirational & Interesting Articles
  • Your Sensual Self
    • Sensual Pregnancy
    • Orgasmic Childbirth
    • Sex in Labor
    • Birth Erotica
  • Laura Shanley
    • About
    • My Book
    • My Blog
    • Contact
PrevAn Unconvention and a new book about unassisted childbirth03 April 2009NextGet Me Out: A History of Childbirth From the Garden of Eden to the Sperm Bank18 January 2010

The Original Birth Attendants

April 20, 2009 0 Comments 0 Likes

I’ve often heard midwives say that midwives were the original birth attendants or that midwifery is the world’s oldest profession (or second oldest profession, as the case may be). Some also claim that we know midwifery is “natural” because even animals have “midwives.” And while I certainly give midwives credit for helping women give birth – both now and in the past – none of the above statements are true. The original birth attendants were friends or family members of the woman giving birth.

Judith Goldsmith writes in her book Childbirth Wisdom from the World’s Oldest Societies that, “Many students of childbirth, however, speak of the midwife as woman’s first helper. In reality, though, even the midwife is a relative newcomer on the scene. In those tribal communities where birth is aided, the assistant is most commonly the woman’s own mother…..A casual reading of anthropology does not always make these close family ties apparent, because often the European writer, seeing things in the light of his own background, referred to the person assisting the mother as the ‘midwife’ whether or not she was called this or considered as such by her own society. Further examination, however, reveals that the so-called midwife was very often a close relative of the mother, with no more special knowledge of birth than any other mother in the tribe. This underlines an important point: in a large part of the world, except in difficult cases, a birth required no more specialized help than the members of a woman’s own family could provide.”

Michel Odent, M.D. echoes these sentiments in his recently released book The Functions of the Orgasms: “The concept of a birth attendant is more recent than is commonly believed, although a mother or mother figure was probably around when a woman was giving birth in primitive societies. This was mostly to protect the privacy of the birth woman against the presence of wandering men or animals. No doubt this is how midwifery began.”

Odent also claims that “Everywhere in the world there has been a tendency to dramatically alter the original role of the birth attendant, to deny the birthing woman’s need for privacy and to socialize childbirth. More often than not, the midwife has become an agent of the cultural milieu, transmitting its specific beliefs and rituals.”

Veronika Sophia Robinson, publisher of the UK magazine The Mother, expresses similar views in her book The Birthkeepers: Reclaiming an Ancient Tradition: “We’ve been led to believe that midwifery is the oldest profession, but this is a romanticized notion, and not a fact. It is perpetuated by practitioners of midwifery and childbirth. When assisted and observed birth did start becoming common place in our history, the attendant was not a specialist in birth, but most usually the mother of the woman in labour.”

As far as animals, some do give birth in the presence of other animals (although most seek seclusion). But these animals cannot be considered “midwives” in any sense of the word. As with tribal cultures, the animals “attending” are simply other members of the pack or herd. You can be sure that none of these “attendants” are sticking their paws inside the mother animal’s vagina, or telling her when and when not to push.

So why does this matter? It matters because as unassisted childbirth grows in popularity, I and other unassisted birth advocates are hearing from more and more midwives and midwife supporters who claim that we’re infringing on their territory or that unassisted birth isn’t “natural.” Some even write that (in the case of an unassisted birth gone wrong) we’re “giving homebirth a bad name.” But the truth is, not only is unassisted childbirth natural, it’s also safe, provided a woman doesn’t live in poverty, and the birth isn’t interfered with either physically or psychologically. Throughout history, healthy tribal women have successfully given birth without medical assistance.

I recognize that many women find the presence of a midwife helpful in birth, and I hope that midwives will continue to be available – to those who want them. But birth doesn’t “belong” to midwives. Nor does it belong to doctors, the AMA or the state. Birth belongs to mothers and babies – and ideally to fathers should they choose to be involved, and it’s time this truth was recognized.

Laura Shanley
Bornfree! The Unassisted Childbirth Page
https://unassistedchildbirth.com
  • homebirth
  • michel odent
  • unassisted childbirth
0 Likes

Related posts

Podcast Podcast about unassisted childbirth with Dr. Jay Warren
November 29, 2016in Podcast 0 Comments 0 Likes

Podcast about unassisted childbirth with Dr. Jay Warren

Book Unassisted Childbirth, 3rd Edition – available now on Amazon!
February 29, 2016in Book 0 Comments 0 Likes

Unassisted Childbirth, 3rd Edition – available now on Amazon!

Unassisted Childbirth Seeking participants for docu-series on outdoor birth
August 8, 2014in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

Seeking participants for docu-series on outdoor birth

Courses Expecting Success! A Positive Approach to Pregnancy and Birth
August 7, 2012in Courses 0 Comments 0 Likes

Expecting Success! A Positive Approach to Pregnancy and Birth

Unassisted Childbirth Cesarean facts from ICAN
April 6, 2012in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

Cesarean facts from ICAN

Unassisted Childbirth Join me at the Trust Birth Conference April 13th-15th
April 3, 2012in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

Join me at the Trust Birth Conference April 13th-15th

Interview Radio show tonight – Unassisted Childbirth
March 19, 2012in Interview 0 Comments 0 Likes

Radio show tonight – Unassisted Childbirth

Book Review Get Me Out: A History of Childbirth From the Garden of Eden to the Sperm Bank
January 18, 2010in Book Review 0 Comments 0 Likes

Get Me Out: A History of Childbirth From the Garden of Eden to the Sperm Bank

Book An Unconvention and a new book about unassisted childbirth
April 3, 2009in Book 0 Comments 0 Likes

An Unconvention and a new book about unassisted childbirth

Unassisted Childbirth Thoughts on 20/20’s Extreme Motherhood show
January 7, 2009in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

Thoughts on 20/20’s Extreme Motherhood show

Unassisted Childbirth Homebirth on ABC’s “20/20” Jan. 2nd
December 11, 2008in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

Homebirth on ABC’s “20/20” Jan. 2nd

Unassisted Childbirth “Freebirthing” to air on the Discovery Health Channel
October 9, 2008in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

“Freebirthing” to air on the Discovery Health Channel

Unassisted Childbirth Reviews and clips of “Outlaw Births”
July 12, 2008in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 1 Likes

Reviews and clips of “Outlaw Births”

Unassisted Childbirth Outlaw Births
July 8, 2008in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

Outlaw Births

Unassisted Childbirth The Homebirth Video That’s Too Hot for YouTube
July 2, 2008in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

The Homebirth Video That’s Too Hot for YouTube

Unassisted Childbirth Associated Press TV segment on Unassisted Childbirth
March 23, 2008in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

Associated Press TV segment on Unassisted Childbirth

Unassisted Childbirth Reflections on the Trust Birth Conference
March 18, 2008in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

Reflections on the Trust Birth Conference

Unassisted Childbirth Requests from the Media
February 22, 2008in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

Requests from the Media

Unassisted Childbirth Censorship on YouTube
August 19, 2007in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

Censorship on YouTube

Unassisted Childbirth A Challenge to Hollywood
May 23, 2007in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

A Challenge to Hollywood

Unassisted Childbirth Article in Canadian national newspaper
May 16, 2007in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

Article in Canadian national newspaper

Unassisted Childbirth Media month in the Shanley household!
May 15, 2007in Unassisted Childbirth 0 Comments 0 Likes

Media month in the Shanley household!

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Other Key Sections:
Unassisted ChildbirthUnassisted Childbirth
Your Sensual SelfYour Sensual Self
Birth StoriesBirth Stories

All other photos and graphics copyright to Laura Shanley, unless otherwise stated.

© 2017 Unassisted Childbirth
Designed by Arun Antony & Co.